A home for cards, comics, and collector finds

Stroud Throws 3 TDs: 9 Texans Cards After Colts Rout

C.J. Stroud threw three touchdowns as Houston routed the Colts 26-3 on Thursday Night Football. Shop 9 in-stock Stroud, Collins and Anderson cards.
2023 Score #302 C.J. Stroud rookie football card

The Houston Texans rolled the Indianapolis Colts 26-3 on Thursday Night Football, and C.J. Stroud was the story on X all night. Stroud threw for 194 yards and three touchdowns, including a 42-yard strike to Nico Collins, while Will Anderson Jr. added a safety and the defense held Indy without a touchdown. David Montgomery chipped in 107 rushing yards as Houston improved to 4-6.

If last night made you a believer again, Big Heads has Texans cards in stock right now. Here are nine C.J. Stroud, Nico Collins and Will Anderson Jr. football cards to add to your collection.

1. 2023 Score #302 C.J. Stroud Rookie

2023 Score #302 C.J. Stroud rookie football card Houston Texans

Start with a rookie. This 2023 Score card comes from Stroud's first NFL season with Houston, when he burst onto the scene as one of the league's top young quarterbacks.

It's an affordable way to own a Stroud rookie after a three-touchdown night.

Shop this card – $1.12

2. 2023 Panini Prestige #314 C.J. Stroud Rookie

2023 Panini Prestige #314 C.J. Stroud rookie football card

Another 2023 rookie-year card, this time from Panini Prestige. Prestige rookies are a favorite of set builders and team collectors alike.

Pair it with the Score rookie above for a quick two-card Stroud rookie run.

Shop this card – $1.00

3. 2023 Panini Chronicles Draft Picks #2 C.J. Stroud

2023 Panini Chronicles Draft Picks #2 C.J. Stroud Ohio State football card

This Draft Picks card shows Stroud in his Ohio State Buckeyes days, before Houston took him second overall in 2023. College cards are a fun way to tell a player's full story in your binder.

Buckeyes fans and Texans fans can both get behind this one.

Shop this card – $1.00

4. 2025 Donruss Optic #162 C.J. Stroud

2025 Donruss Optic #162 C.J. Stroud Houston Texans football card

Donruss Optic's chrome-style finish makes this one of the sharpest current Stroud cards. It shows him in the Texans uniform he wore to carve up the Colts.

A great everyday pickup for any Houston PC.

Shop this card – $1.00

5. 2024 Panini Select #42 C.J. Stroud

2024 Panini Select #42 C.J. Stroud football card

Panini Select is known for its shiny, tiered design, and this base card from 2024 fits nicely next to your Optic and Prestige Stroud cards.

It rounds out a five-card Stroud lineup from college to today.

Shop this card – $1.00

6. 2025 Donruss Optic #143 Nico Collins

2025 Donruss Optic #143 Nico Collins Houston Texans football card

Collins got Houston rolling Thursday with a 42-yard touchdown catch from Stroud in the first quarter. He is Stroud's top target, and this Optic card captures the Texans' best receiver in a clean chrome design.

Pair it with the Stroud Optic for a matching QB-to-WR set.

Shop this card – $1.00

7. 2025 Topps Signature Class #76 Nico Collins

2025 Topps Signature Class #76 Nico Collins football card

Topps Signature Class is one of the newer football products on the market, and this Collins base card is an easy way to add him to your collection.

At this price, it's a no-brainer add-on.

Shop this card – $1.00

8. 2025 Score #9 Will Anderson Jr. Sack Attack

2025 Score #9 Will Anderson Jr. Sack Attack insert football card

Will Anderson Jr. gave the Texans two points Thursday night with a safety. This Sack Attack insert is made for a pass rusher like him and is a fun card for defense-first collectors.

Shop this card – $1.00

9. 2025 Panini Absolute #24 Will Anderson Jr.

2025 Panini Absolute #24 Will Anderson Jr. football card

Round out your Texans stack with Anderson's 2025 Panini Absolute base card. Houston's defense held the Colts to just a field goal, and Anderson is the face of that unit.

It's a simple, affordable way to add the Texans' star edge rusher to your binder.

Shop this card – $1.00

Build your Texans collection

Houston's 26-3 win gave Texans fans plenty to cheer about. Most of these cards are one-of-a-kind in our shop, so grab your favorites before they're gone. Shop all sports cards at Big Heads.